Insurance Fraud Investigation & Litigation

Comprehensive legal solutions for detecting, investigating, and prosecuting insurance fraud

Insurance Fraud Overview

Insurance fraud encompasses false or exaggerated claims, premium evasion, underwriting misrepresentation, and organized schemes to defraud insurers. These violations impose billions in annual losses, drive premium increases, and undermine the risk-pooling foundations of insurance markets.

Modern insurance fraud ranges from opportunistic individual exaggeration to sophisticated organized crime networks orchestrating staged accidents, phantom clinics, and mass claim mills. Effective detection requires data analytics, surveillance, medical record review, and coordination between Special Investigation Units (SIUs), law enforcement, and regulatory bodies.

Common Insurance Fraud Schemes

Hard Fraud: Deliberate Fabrication

Intentional staging of losses—including vehicle accidents, property fires, theft claims, or false death claims—to collect insurance proceeds. Often involves falsified police reports, forged documents, and witness collusion.

Soft Fraud: Exaggeration & Inflation

Embellishment of legitimate claims by inflating damages, adding unrelated injuries, or claiming pre-existing damage. While less egregious, soft fraud collectively generates substantial losses and is widespread.

Medical Provider Fraud

Healthcare providers billing for services not rendered, upcoding procedures, performing unnecessary treatments, or operating phantom clinics. Common in workers' compensation, personal injury protection (PIP), and health insurance.

Premium Fraud & Underwriting Misrepresentation

Providing false information during application to secure lower premiums: misrepresenting driving records, concealing material facts, fronting (listing low-risk individuals as primary policyholders), or worker misclassification in workers' comp.

Staged Accidents & Swoop-and-Squat

Organized schemes involving deliberate vehicle collisions to generate fraudulent bodily injury and property damage claims. Often coupled with complicit medical providers, attorneys, and tow truck operators.

Workers' Compensation Fraud

False claims of workplace injury, exaggeration of disabilities, working while collecting benefits, or employer fraud through employee misclassification and payroll underreporting.

Life Insurance & Death Claim Fraud

Faked deaths, murder-for-profit schemes, stranger-originated life insurance (STOLI), and concealment of material health information during underwriting.

Phased Investigation Process

Phase 1 – Red Flag Identification & SIU Referral

Claims adjuster identification of fraud indicators: inconsistent statements, suspicious medical billing patterns, prior claim history, public records discrepancies. Referral to Special Investigation Unit (SIU) with preliminary analysis.

Phase 2 – Document Collection & Data Analysis

Acquisition of claim files, medical records, police reports, recorded statements, and third-party documentation. Database searches (NICB, ISO ClaimSearch, LexisNexis) to identify patterns and co-conspirators. Social media and public records investigation.

Phase 3 – Surveillance & Field Investigation

Physical surveillance to document activities inconsistent with claimed injuries or damages. Scene investigation for accident reconstruction or arson investigation. Canvassing for independent witnesses. Undercover operations for organized fraud rings.

Phase 4 – Medical & Expert Review

Independent medical examinations (IME), peer review of treatment necessity, biomechanical analysis of injury causation. Forensic accounting for financial fraud. Fire investigation and engineering analysis for property claims.

Phase 5 – Legal Strategy & Referral

Coordination with defense counsel on claim denial strategy. Referral to prosecutors (state insurance fraud bureau, district attorney, DOJ). Preparation of Suspicious Activity Reports (SARs) and regulatory notifications. Civil litigation planning.

Critical Evidence Categories

  • Claim Documentation: Applications, recorded statements, proof of loss forms, medical authorizations, claim correspondence
  • Medical Records: Treatment notes, diagnostic imaging, pharmacy records, billing statements, independent medical exams
  • Surveillance Evidence: Video/photo documentation, activity logs, GPS tracking data (where legally permissible)
  • Digital Evidence: Social media posts, metadata analysis, email/text communications, telematics data (for auto claims)
  • Financial Records: Bank statements, tax returns, employment records, proof of premium payments or non-payment
  • Expert Opinions: Accident reconstruction, medical causation, arson investigation, biomechanical analysis, handwriting analysis

Evidence must satisfy authentication, relevance, and hearsay requirements; medical records require HIPAA-compliant authorization or subpoena.

Litigation & Defense Strategy

Effective defense against fraudulent claims requires:

  • Affirmative Defenses: Material misrepresentation, policy rescission, fraud in the inducement, breach of cooperation clause
  • Discovery Strategy: Depositions of claimants, medical providers, and witnesses; subpoenas to social media platforms; IME and EUO (Examination Under Oath)
  • Motion Practice: Summary judgment on policy rescission, motions to compel IME attendance, sanctions for discovery abuse
  • Expert Testimony: Medical causation experts, accident reconstructionists, fraud investigation specialists, economic damages experts
  • Counterclaims: Affirmative fraud claims seeking treble damages, attorney fees, and costs under state fraud statutes

Coordination of civil litigation with parallel criminal investigation requires careful privilege management and strategic disclosure decisions.

Fraud Prevention Programs & Best Practices

  • Deploy predictive analytics and machine learning for claim triage and fraud scoring
  • Establish robust Special Investigation Units (SIUs) with dedicated fraud investigators
  • Participate in industry data-sharing consortia (NICB, ISO, state fraud bureaus)
  • Implement comprehensive underwriting controls: database checks, predictive modeling, document verification
  • Conduct fraud awareness training for claims adjusters, underwriters, and agents
  • Maintain whistleblower hotlines and anti-fraud policy communications
  • Leverage telematics, IoT sensors, and blockchain for claims verification

Expected Outcomes & Impact

Successful insurance fraud investigations deliver:

  • Claim Denials & Savings: Avoided payouts on fraudulent claims; policy rescissions for material misrepresentation
  • Criminal Convictions: Felony convictions carrying prison sentences, restitution orders, and probation; dismantling of fraud rings
  • Civil Judgments: Recovery of prior payments through subrogation, unjust enrichment, or fraud counterclaims; treble damages under state statutes
  • Deterrence Effect: Publicized prosecutions deter opportunistic fraud; industry cooperation disrupts organized schemes
  • Premium Impact: Fraud control programs reduce loss ratios, enabling competitive pricing and improved profitability

Investigation timelines vary from 2-6 months for simple hard fraud to 12-24 months for complex organized schemes requiring multi-agency coordination.

Confronting Suspected Insurance Fraud?

Our team combines insurance defense expertise, investigative resources, and litigation experience to protect insurers from fraudulent claims and maximize recovery on paid claims.

Request SIU Consultation